We have come up with a list of all those who have played at least one 1st XI match for Scarborough Cricket Club whether it be a league match or a cup tie since World War II. They are listed below in number order.
It has been difficult to find accurate records prior to WWII for 1st XI players, and equally challenging to locate records for 2nd and 3rd team games.
| Cap No | Initial (s) | Surname | Year First Played |
| 1 | AN | Adamson | 1946 |
| 2 | ES | Alcock | 1946 |
| 3 | JF | Allan | 1946 |
| 4 | CR | Atkinson | 1946 |
| 5 | G | Bowland | 1946 |
| 6 | FS | Brooker | 1946 |
| 7 | R | Candler | 1946 |
| 8 | S | Clark | 1946 |
| 9 | AB | Clarke | 1946 |
| 10 | J | Crowther | 1946 |
| 11 | LF | Franklin | 1946 |
| 12 | R | Grice | 1946 |
| 13 | L | Halstead | 1946 |
| 14 | S | Hardwick | 1946 |
| 15 | EHM | Hood | 1946 |
| 16 | G | Hovington | 1946 |
| 17 | FG | Kendall | 1946 |
| 18 | JR | Knowles | 1946 |
| 19 | E | Lester | 1946 |
| 20 | S | Lewsey | 1946 |
| 21 | LE | Liddle | 1946 |
| 22 | J | Meads | 1946 |
| 23 | MD | Munby | 1946 |
| 24 | K | Pickles | 1946 |
| 25 | JA | Richardson | 1946 |
| 26 | GH | Smith | 1946 |
| 27 | JD | Snowball | 1946 |
| 28 | F | Temple | 1946 |
| 29 | EH | Turner | 1946 |
| 30 | F | Winn | 1946 |
| 31 | N | Wortley | 1946 |
| 32 | CW | Foord | 1947 |
| 33 | J | Johnson | 1947 |
| 34 | JC | Moss | 1947 |
| 35 | G | Newham | 1947 |
| 36 | J | Rigby | 1947 |
| 37 | WK | Bradshaw | 1948 |
| 38 | J | Cammish | 1948 |
| 39 | GH | Dennis | 1948 |
| 40 | CE | Hall | 1948 |
| 41 | R | Hobson | 1948 |
| 42 | P | Judge | 1948 |
| 43 | FH | Stephenson | 1948 |
| 44 | J | Sunley | 1948 |
| 45 | F | Hind | 1949 |
| 46 | P | Race | 1949 |
| 47 | KC | Stockwell | 1949 |
| 48 | HO | Crosskill | 1950 |
| 49 | J | Pottage | 1950 |
| 50 | P | Rochford | 1950 |
| 51 | RA | Diggle | 1951 |
| 52 | J | Lister | 1951 |
| 53 | K | Hudson | 1952 |
| 54 | BC | Moor | 1952 |
| 55 | GM | Shepherdson | 1952 |
| 56 | R | Halton | 1953 |
| 57 | A | Marston | 1953 |
| 58 | E | McKinna | 1953 |
| 59 | DM | Rines | 1953 |
| 60 | JR | Burnet | 1954 |
| 61 | JA | Claughton | 1954 |
| 62 | DW | Barnes | 1955 |
| 63 | J | Hutton | 1955 |
| 64 | G | Mitchell | 1955 |
| 65 | BGR | Rolls | 1955 |
| 66 | R | Coward | 1956 |
| 67 | IK | Cutts | 1956 |
| 68 | M | Naylor | 1956 |
| 69 | DM | Douglas | 1957 |
| 70 | AJ | Moor | 1958 |
| 71 | GB | Wood | 1958 |
| 72 | GR | Bloom | 1959 |
| 73 | H | Halliday | 1960 |
| 74 | GH | Bowman | 1961 |
| 75 | R (Bob) | Harrison | 1961 |
| 76 | KA | Calvert | 1962 |
| 77 | M | Hill | 1962 |
| 78 | C | Warren | 1962 |
| 79 | C | Clifford | 1963 |
| 80 | G | Downes | 1963 |
| 81 | G | Metcalfe | 1963 |
| 82 | F | Robson | 1963 |
| 83 | J | Oxley | 1964 |
| 84 | CW | Kirby | 1965 |
| 85 | M | Kirkland | 1965 |
| 86 | J | Waring | 1965 |
| 87 | M | Heath | 1966 |
| 88 | JB | Mitchell | 1966 |
| 89 | JE | Townsley | 1966 |
| 90 | A | Hampshire | 1968 |
| 91 | C | Oxtoby | 1968 |
| 92 | B | Rennard | 1968 |
| 93 | C | Hurd | 1969 |
| 94 | A | Dobson | 1970 |
| 95 | P | Hart | 1970 |
| 96 | W | Pincher | 1970 |
| 97 | E | Richardson | 1971 |
| 98 | W | Mustoe | 1972 |
| 99 | M | Davison | 1973 |
| 100 | R | Tye | 1973 |
| 101 | PS | Glaves | 1974 |
| 102 | M | Stewart | 1974 |
| 103 | D | Bradbury | 1975 |
| 104 | M | Shepherdson | 1975 |
| 105 | R | Sherwood | 1975 |
| 106 | D | Kneeshaw | 1976 |
| 107 | P | Woodliffe | 1976 |
| 108 | SJ | Dennis | 1977 |
| 109 | M | Brown | 1978 |
| 110 | S | Gregory | 1978 |
| 111 | J | Precious | 1978 |
| 112 | DB | Close | 1979 |
| 113 | CH | Stephenson | 1979 |
| 114 | D | Byas | 1980 |
| 115 | CC | Clifford | 1980 |
| 116 | P | Ellis | 1980 |
| 117 | R | Noble | 1980 |
| 118 | C | Southwell | 1980 |
| 119 | N | West | 1980 |
| 120 | A | Dalby | 1981 |
| 121 | NP | Tubbs | 1982 |
| 122 | RE | Pockley | 1983 |
| 123 | TN | Watts | 1983 |
| 124 | RV | Southwell | 1984 |
| 125 | BA | Young | 1984 |
| 126 | CW | Burdass | 1985 |
| 127 | AJ | Grayson | 1985 |
| 128 | N | Rounding | 1985 |
| 129 | D | Woodhead | 1985 |
| 130 | P | Woodhead | 1985 |
| 131 | PN | Anderson | 1986 |
| 132 | CM | Good | 1986 |
| 133 | SCE | Hardy | 1986 |
| 134 | CT | Hugill | 1986 |
| 135 | AD | Towse | 1986 |
| 136 | MWD | Cowell | 1987 |
| 137 | S | Gormley | 1987 |
| 138 | PM | Hanby | 1987 |
| 139 | N | Stephenson | 1987 |
| 140 | P | Bowes | 1988 |
| 141 | N | Pratt | 1988 |
| 142 | P | Robinson | 1988 |
| 143 | SW | Prest | 1989 |
| 144 | JT | Riley | 1989 |
| 145 | AP | Wood | 1989 |
| 146 | N | Cowton | 1990 |
| 147 | D | Greenlay | 1990 |
| 148 | Alistair | Lyth | 1990 |
| 149 | CD | Watson | 1990 |
| 150 | RM | Pallister | 1991 |
| 151 | G | Pickup | 1991 |
| 152 | IJ | Houseman | 1992 |
| 153 | DN | Barton | 1993 |
| 154 | N | Elvidge | 1993 |
| 155 | MA | Welford | 1993 |
| 156 | BJ | Cleaver | 1994 |
| 157 | D | Gormley | 1994 |
| 158 | M | Barnett | 1995 |
| 159 | MJ | Wells | 1995 |
| 160 | GJ | Wilson | 1995 |
| 161 | DS | Harland | 1996 |
| 162 | B | Rowan | 1996 |
| 163 | CRE | Harrison | 1997 |
| 164 | AM | Holden | 1997 |
| 165 | IJ | Philliskirk | 1997 |
| 166 | PJ | Seed | 1997 |
| 167 | CE | Cuffy | 1998 |
| 168 | GR | Jones | 1998 |
| 169 | RMS | Weston | 1998 |
| 170 | C | White | 1998 |
| 171 | C | Allen | 1999 |
| 172 | NL | Fletcher | 1999 |
| 173 | RG | Gilbert | 1999 |
| 174 | Adam | Lyth | 1999 |
| 175 | BN | Wigney | 1999 |
| 176 | AJ | Gallagher | 2000 |
| 177 | RJ | Barlow | 2001 |
| 178 | VJ | Craven | 2001 |
| 179 | AKD | Gray | 2001 |
| 180 | TG | Whitmarsh | 2001 |
| 181 | C | Batchelor | 2002 |
| 182 | C | Dove | 2002 |
| 183 | CJ | Heron | 2002 |
| 184 | W | Mallory | 2002 |
| 185 | RC | Swiers | 2002 |
| 186 | A | Wellford | 2002 |
| 187 | PW | Beard | 2003 |
| 188 | Ashley | Lyth | 2003 |
| 189 | C | Sanderson | 2003 |
| 190 | RJ | Brooke | 2004 |
| 191 | A | Kundi | 2004 |
| 192 | D | Morris | 2004 |
| 193 | P | Pateman | 2004 |
| 194 | TJ | Pateman | 2004 |
| 195 | RG | Arendse | 2005 |
| 196 | L | Cunnah | 2005 |
| 197 | J | Dickinson | 2005 |
| 198 | R | Gilbert | 2005 |
| 199 | MAK | Lawson | 2005 |
| 200 | J | Rewcroft | 2005 |
| 201 | G | Rounthwaite | 2005 |
| 202 | N | Zacrewski | 2005 |
| 203 | KD | Aphale | 2006 |
| 204 | KS | Bansil | 2006 |
| 205 | CR | Gilbert | 2006 |
| 206 | PG | Holdsworth | 2006 |
| 207 | R | Malthouse | 2006 |
| 208 | M | Thompson | 2006 |
| 209 | T | Bromet | 2007 |
| 210 | T | Bumby | 2007 |
| 211 | W | Gibson | 2007 |
| 212 | SJ | Hogg | 2007 |
| 213 | M | Laidler | 2007 |
| 214 | SR | Tennant | 2007 |
| 215 | S | Anderson | 2008 |
| 216 | S | Cooper | 2008 |
| 217 | JM | Finch | 2008 |
| 218 | C | Gibson | 2008 |
| 219 | J | Padmore | 2008 |
| 220 | HP | Rinke | 2008 |
| 221 | O | Stephenson | 2008 |
| 222 | A | Stones | 2008 |
| 223 | A | Clarke | 2009 |
| 224 | MW | Tennant | 2009 |
| 225 | HDM | Evans | 2010 |
| 226 | J | Holt | 2010 |
| 227 | A | Simpson | 2010 |
| 228 | M | Kay | 2011 |
| 229 | Ash | Kundi | 2011 |
| 230 | TH | Precious | 2011 |
| 231 | TD | Bruce | 2012 |
| 232 | A | Hunter | 2012 |
| 233 | MD | Kay | 2012 |
| 234 | S | Sharma | 2012 |
| 235 | T | Smith | 2012 |
| 236 | S | Carver | 2013 |
| 237 | C | Ferrie | 2013 |
| 238 | R | Green | 2013 |
| 239 | C | Grey | 2013 |
| 240 | J | Read | 2013 |
| 241 | A | Carrie | 2014 |
| 242 | D | Foster | 2014 |
| 243 | A | Green | 2014 |
| 244 | D | Grey | 2014 |
| 245 | C | Hodgson | 2014 |
| 246 | K | Howard | 2014 |
| 247 | C | Joyce | 2014 |
| 248 | J | Mainprize | 2014 |
| 249 | J | Pick | 2014 |
| 250 | C | Roberts | 2014 |
| 251 | P | Shally | 2014 |
| 252 | M | Watson | 2014 |
| 253 | J | Welford | 2014 |
| 254 | TWP | Bussey | 2015 |
| 255 | R | Gibson | 2015 |
| 256 | B | Milburn | 2015 |
| 257 | K | Wilkinson | 2015 |
| 258 | D | Brannan | 2016 |
| 259 | E | Cooper | 2016 |
| 260 | BD | Elvidge | 2016 |
| 261 | D | Mills | 2016 |
| 262 | R | Ngvara | 2016 |
| 263 | J | Bryant | 2017 |
| 264 | KR | Fenwick | 2017 |
| 265 | C | Hopper | 2017 |
| 266 | B | Scott | 2017 |
| 267 | D | Snowball | 2017 |
| 268 | LJ | Tinsley | 2017 |
| 269 | J | Anderson | 2018 |
| 270 | S | Drury | 2018 |
| 271 | A | Exton | 2018 |
| 272 | M | Graves | 2018 |
| 273 | L | Gray | 2018 |
| 274 | T | Pratt | 2018 |
| 275 | S | Ullyott | 2018 |
| 276 | A | Eustace | 2019 |
| 277 | J | Ingle | 2019 |
| 278 | M | Pillans | 2019 |
| 279 | C | Rudd | 2019 |
